Women in the Employment Labyrinth: A Qualitative Study of Women's Strategies for Achieving Job Opportunities (Case of study: working women of Mashhad in 2018-2019)

Document Type : -

Authors

1 Assistant Professor of Sociology, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad

2 Master's student of Social Sciences, Faculty of Literature and Humanities Dr. Ali Shariati, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Mashhad, Iran

3 Assistant Professor of Demography, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad

10.30465/ws.2023.39153.3426

Abstract

Introduction
Employment is a key area for growth and self-fulfillment. Women have always faced many challenges since long ago, especially in developing countries, to achieve this goal under the influence of various historical, social and cultural contexts. Employment of women in Iran has an unequal position compared to men. These gender differences in the labor market can be identified both through the statistics and figures published about the level of economic participation of women in the Iranian society and through the discriminations in the work environment, such as taking low and less advantageous organizational positions by women compared to men. Despite the national development programs as well as the development of women's skills, abilities and education in recent years, the challenges facing them in the labor market still remain. Therefore, the present research aims to identify and achieve a coherent understanding of women's strategies to achieve employment with a qualitative and in-depth approach. In this regard, the conditions governing the adoption of any strategy by working women in medium job positions should be determined in terms of income and status.
Literature review
Recent studies have confirmed the fact that the process of finding employment for women is influenced by some macro-demographic, cultural-social, individual, psychological and economic factors. In general, the findings of these studies, which are often carried out with a quantitative approach, indicate that women based on several variables such as age, education, capabilities, self-confidence, self-belief, having family support and access to financial resources, have different experiences in the job search process. The results of some other sociological researches show that a major part of women's bad luck in obtaining favorable job opportunities is due to the lack of attention of government and public institutions and inappropriate policies in order to ensure women have balanced privileges in the workplace. It should be noted that the findings of some other studies show that the media and social networks facilitate the job search process, especially in the field of controlling and adjusting traditional structures.
Methodology
The present research, with a qualitative approach and based on interpretive methodology (grounded theory), has investigated the experiences and identification of women's strategies in obtaining job opportunities. The statistical population of this research consists of working women with average job positions in terms of income and status in Mashhad. In order to determine the sample size, two methods of targeted sampling and snowball were used, thus 19 working women were interviewed. In order to achieve theoretical saturation, the researchers implemented and analyzed the data after conducting each interview in order to identify the hidden aspects of the data and non-transparent data. In the continuation, the existing findings were completed by taking new interviews until reaching a clear picture of the phenomenon under study. Based on this, the data collection process continued until reaching the saturation stage.
Validity and reliability in the present research were measured using Guba and Lincoln's four-step approach. Based on this, numerous referrals and long-term presence in job search centers and continuous observation of the behavior of the main actors of the labor market on both sides of job seekers and suppliers were made. Also, the diversity of the respondents in terms of having multiple career records and experiences and different socio-economic bases was emphasized during sampling and data collection. Finally, the use of open-ended questions during interviews and the systematic coding of interviews at an open, axial and selective level during data analysis was one of the other strategies of researchers to fulfill the criteria of validity, transferability, reliability and verifiability in this research.
Findings
The analysis of the data of the present research led to the formulation of the central phenomenon under the title "Women's job search: balance between identity search, security seeking and independence seeking". This phenomenon has been affected by a set of causal conditions such as "unmet economic needs", "concentration of working women in peripheral social networks" and "role-identity challenges". Also, the background conditions include "increasing expansion of unstable job opportunities in the labor market" and "evolution in the criteria for validating women in Iranian society" and intervening conditions such as "education", "marriage and economic experiences related to it" and "lived experience of women in Father's house" have had an effect on the identified central phenomenon. To face the central phenomenon, the studied women use strategies such as "wandering in the labor market", "entrepreneurial experiences", "job search based on previous experiences", and "relying on peripheral social networks "," utilizing sexual capital and appeal to official organizations. Also, they have reported consequences such as "prioritization of income over job security", "redefinition of women's identity based on employment", "relative economic independence of women" and "gradual feminization of the labor market".
Discussion
The results of the research show that women, under the influence of positive or motivational factors, tend to get a job outside their place of residence. It can be said that women who have pursued the job search process at least once in a serious and goal-oriented manner have been affected by factors such as unmet economic needs, the density of working women in social networks, role and identity challenges, as well as having professional skills and qualifications.
 Finally, the results of this research confirm the findings of some previous studies that women's individual characteristics are more effective than social, cultural and structural factors in their job search process. In this effort to enter the labor market by women, two main elements under the title of job security and identification are given priority over economic independence. An important part of middle-class women's efforts for employment can be seen in the light of this prioritization. In fact, being in job positions attracts women's interest more than to achieve economic benefits, because of its identity and dignity creation. Finally, in the shadow of employment and in the process of searching for desirable job opportunities, women learn about independent and effective lifestyles in society.
Therefore, in the policy making of the employment field, emphasis should be placed on creating a platform for flexible career experiences for women, taking into account the requirements of their personal and family life. Also, the optimization of the legal protection system for women in the workplace should be considered.

Keywords

Main Subjects


Abbaszadeh, Mohammad.. (2012). Validity and reliability in qualitative researches. Journal of Applied Sociology, 23(1), 19-34.
Alavizadh, Seyed Amir Mohammad., Shamsoldini, Ali., & Hosseini, Fatemeh. (2017). Studying the Obstacles of Rural Women’s Employment in Balavelayat Village Located in Kashmar City. Quarterly Journal of Women and Society, 7(spatial), pp: 195-218.
Amadnia Shirin, Ghlibaf kamel Athena. (2017). Women-Headed Households in Tehran: A Qualitative Study of Their Experiences, Challenges and Capacities. Refahj, 17 (65), pp: :103-136.
Arabmzar, Abbas., Sadegh Alipour, Mohammad., & Zare Niyakooki, Yaser. (2014). An Analysis of socio-Economic factors affecting The Women Employment in Iran. Journal of Economics and Modeling, 5(17-18), pp: 75-91.
Arman, Seyed aziz., Farazmand, Hassan., & Danesh, Hamideh. (2015). Impact of ICT on Women's Participation Rate in the Labor Force. Quarterly Journal of Social Development (Previously Human Development), 9(4), pp: 161-184.
Badsar, Mohammad., Soltani, Shirin., & Ghasemi, Mehdi. (2019). Investigating the Mediating Role of Self-esteem and Risk taking in the Analysis of Factors Influencing Rural women's self-employment. Quarterly Journal of Women and Society, 9(36), pp:16-38.
Bussemakers, Carlijn., van Oosterhout, Kars., Kraaykamp, Gerbert., & Spierings, Niels. (2017). Women’s Worldwide Education–employment Connection: A Multilevel Analysis of the Moderating Impact of Economic, Political, and Cultural Contexts. World Development, 99,  pp: 28-41.
Castillo-Montoya, Milagros. (2016). Preparing for interview research: The interview protocol refinement framework. The Qualitative Report, 21(5), pp: 811-831.
Coley, Rebekah Levine., & Lombardi, Caitlin McPherran. (2014). Low-income women’s employment experiences and their financial, personal, and family well-being. Family Psychology, 28(1),pp: 1-10.
Cornwall, Andrea. (2016). Women's empowerment: What works?. Journal of International Development, 28(3), pp: 342-359.
Darvishi Fard, Ali Asghar; Jesk, Mitra & Faizipour, Khadijah. (2014). The lived experience of women working in production workshops. Social work. 2(5), pp: 77-108.
Dhanaraj, Sowmya., & Mahambare, Vidya. (2019). Family structure, education and women’s employment in rural India. World Development, 115, pp: 17-29.
Dizji, Munira & Badri Bookseller, Arash. (2015). Investigating factors affecting women's employment with an emphasis on the use of (ICT). Women and family studies. 9 (34). pp: 73-93.
Drydakis, Nick., Sidiropoulou, Katerina., Patnaik, Swetketu., Selmanovic, Sandra., & Bozani, Vasiliki. (2018). Masculine vs Feminine Personality Traits and Women's Employment Outcomes in Britain: A Field Experiment. International Journal of Manpower, 39(4), pp: 621-630.
Fadelnia, Gharib& Hashemi, Rezvan. (2015). Analysis of Socio – Cultural Inhibitory Beliefs of Rural Women's Participation in Planning and Management Process of Rural Development (Case Study: The City of Rustam). Quarterly Journal of Women and Society, 6(21),  pp: 41-66.
Feizpour, Mohammad Ali, Salehi Firouzabadi, Golsa & Dehmobed, Babak. (2015). An Investigation into the Development Level of Job Market across Genders in Iran. Women Studies, 5(10), pp: 89-109.
Foroutan, Yaghoob. (2008). Women’s employment, religion and multiculturalism: Socio-demographic emphasis. Population Research, 25(1),pp: 63-90.
Garikipati, Supriya. (2012). Microcredit and women's empowerment: Through the lens of time‐use data from rural India. Development and Change, 43(3), pp: 719-750.
Hakim, Catherine. (2010). Erotic capital. European sociological review, 26(5), pp: 499-518.
Heidari Sareban, Vakil. (2012). Prioritizing Major Barriers to Rural Women's Entrepreneurship, Using AHP Method. Case study: Ardabil province. Women's Studies Sociological and Psychological, 10(2),pp: 159-177.
Hezarjaribi, Jafar., & Pilevari, Azam. (2012). Recognizing the Social Barriers for Female Staff of Bank Melli in Tehran to Access Managerial Positions. Woman in Development & Politics, 10(2), pp: 25-42.
Hosseininia, Gholamhossein., Yaghoubi Farani, Ahmad., & Seyedin, Reza. (2014). Measuring factors affecting Female entrepreneur's business performance in rural areas of Mianeh County. Woman in Development & Politics, 12(4), pp: 545-558.
Iravani, Mohammad Reza. (2010). Women's Education, Employment And Unemployment In Iran. Rajagiri Journal of Social Development, 1(2), pp: 31- 44.
Jamini, Davood., Taghdisi, Ahmad., Alipoor, Khaked., & Faizi, Sheher. (2015). Factor analysis of hindering and drawing variables of Entrepreneurship Development among Rural Women in Iran: Case Study of Ravansar Township. Women's Studies Sociological and Psychological, 13(1),pp: 63-88.
Jamshidi, Alireza; Gemini, Dawood & Nazari Sarmazeh, Hamid. (2014). Studying Driving Forces and Hampering Factors Affecting Development of Rural Women's Entrepreneurship in Miankoh District, Ardal Township. Quarterly Journal of Women and Society, 5(17),pp: 75-94.
Karimi Moghari, Zahra & Jahan Tigh, Elham. (2013). Factors affecting the informal employment of young women in Iran. Socio-psychological studies of women. 12 (3). pp: 115-140.
Karimi Moughari, Zahra., Nazifi Nainie, Minoo., & Abbaspour, Sahar. (2013). Evaluating the Economic factors affecting employment of women in Iran Using artificial neural network approach. Women's Studies Sociological and Psychological, 11(3), pp: 53-80.
Karimi, Zahra., Jahantigh, Elhma., & EbrahimiPourfaez, Sahand. (2016). WomenStatus in Labor Market of Muslim and non-MuslimDeveloping Countries (1995-2010). Women Studies, 7(15), pp: 155-178.
Kermani, Mahdi., AsgharpourMasouleh, Ahmad Reza., & Asemani, Fatemeh. (2019). The performance of women as a compensation agent in the household economy; Qualitative analysis of married women's narratives in Mashhad based on grounded theory. Quarterly Journal of Women and Society, 10(38), 63-86.
Kermani, Mehdi (2014). Empowerment of headed household women; fromtheory to practice. Tehran: Shahr.
Kheiridoost, Zahra., & Nsiri, Bahareh. (2015). A Comparative Study of Women Development Indices in Iran and Its Neighboring Countries. Women Studies, 6(0), pp: 47-65.
Maleki, Zohreh., & Ataee, Mohammad. (2017). Identify solutions to overcome barriers to women's job improvement in governmental organizations(Case Study: Tax Qazvin). Journal of Development & Evolution Mnagement, 8(special issue),  pp: 46-56.
Mila Elmi, Zahra., Zaroki, Shahyar., & Mahdavi Chabok, Sayyedeh Mona. (2014). Measurement of effective demographic factors on women's economic participation in urban areas of Iran. Woman in Development & Politics, 12(4), pp: 525-544.
Nahovi, Abuzar & Ghorbani, Mohammad. (2012). Investigating the Factors Affecting Women's Participation ‎in the Labor Market (Case study: the City of Mashhad)‎. Women and Family Studies, 5(17), pp: 147-158.
Naqdi, Asadullah & Ruayin Tan, Mahbubeh. (2015). Mental and environmental styles of employment among women working in the informal sector (case study of passages in Hamadan city). Sociology of lifestyle. 2 (5). pp: 175-219.
nezamevandchgeni, Zahri., & saraei, Hasan. (2013). The Factors Affecting Women’s Labor Force Participation in Tehran. Social Development & Welfare Planning, 5(15), pp: 1-45.
Noghani, Mohsen; Mohammadi, Fardin & Kermani, Mahdi (2018). Theory creation in qualitative studies (an applied approach to grounded theory). Mashhad: Ferdowsi University of Mashhad.
Nomura, Kyoko., & Gohchi, Kengo. (2012). Impact of gender-based career obstacles on the working status of women physicians in Japan. Social science & medicine, 75(9),  pp: 1612-1616.
Rajaeian. Mohammad Mehdi, & Bagherpour, parichehr. (2015). A Study on influential Factors of Women’s Employment Rate Using System Dynamics Approach. Women's Studies Sociological and Psychological, 13(2), 7-36.
Ritzer, George (2016). Contemporary sociological theory and its classical roots: the basics. Translation: Khalil Mirzaei and Ali Sarabi. Tehran: Sociologists Publications.
Sabinejad, Mohammad Reza (2008). employment of women; Factors, consequences and approaches (from the point of view of social management). employment of women; A collection of articles from the Office of Women's Studies and Research. pp: 104-21.
Sadeghi, Rasoul., & Shahabi, Zahra. (2019). The Paradox of Work and Mothering: The Experience of Transition to Motherhood of Employed Women. Journal of Applied Sociology, 30(1), pp:91-104.
Sameti, Majeed., & Pash zanoosi, Masoomeh. (2013). Impact of GenderInequalities in employment and education on Human Development Index (1990-2010. Women's Studies Sociological and Psychological, 11(4), pp: 7-33.
Sharifi, Zainab; Irvani, Houshang & Daneshvar Ameri, Zila (2014). Analysis of promoting and inhibiting factors in the development of rural women's employment in Najaf Abad city. Women and society. 6 (1). pp: 1-20.
Shatrian, Mohsen & Ashnui, Amir. (2011). Investigating Cultural And Social Factors Affecting The Employment Of Women In Badrood City. Social Development. 6 (3). pp: 133-146.
Steiber, Nadia., & Haas, Barbara. (2012). Advances in explaining women's employment patterns. Socio-Economic Review, 10(2), pp: 343-367.
 Taghizadeh, Houshang; Soltani Faskandis, Gholamreza & Shokri, Abdul Hossein. (2012). Identifying Barriers to Women's Promotion to Managerial ‎Positions (A case study)‎. Women and Family Studies, 5(17), pp:33-50.
Tajeddin, Mohammad Bagher., & Ramadi Valla, Leyla. (2014). National media and the empowerment of women-headed household (case study: women-headed household of Tehran- 18 region). Women's Strategic Studies, 17(65), pp: 119-161.
Wakabayashi, Chizuko., & Donato, Katharine. M. (2005). The consequences of caregiving: Effects on women’s employment and earnings. Population Research and Policy Review, 24(5), pp: 467-488.
Yacoubi Farani, Ahmed., Soleimani, Atiyeh & Mohadi, Reza. (2014). Analysis of factors affecting rural women's entrepreneurship. Socio-psychological studies of women. 12 (4). pp:42-7.
Yaghoubi Farani, Ahmad & Soleymani, Atieh. (2015). The impact of personal characteristics on rural women entrepreneurs’ success in Hamedan Province. Woman in Development & Politics, 13(1), pp: 113-130.
Yaghoubi, Jafar., Najafloo, Parisa., & Haghverdi, Elaheh. (2016). Assessing different aspects and barriers of self-employment among agricultural female students (Case study: Zanjan University). Woman in Development & Politics, 14(3), pp: 343-360.
Yousefy, Alireza., & Baratali, Maryam. (2011). Women, employment and higher education schoolings. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, 15, pp: 3861-3869.
Iranian Statistics Center (1401). Data and statistical information. Taken from: https://www.amar.org.ir
Data Bank World Bank. Labor force, female (% of total labor force) - Iran, Islamic Rep.Taken From:  https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SL.TLF.TOTL.FE.ZS?end=2021&locations=IR&start=2021&view=map